Experimental facts of the photoelectric effect and the failure of wave theory
A solar calculator works only in light — light frees charges.
The photoelectric effect is the emission of electrons from a metal when light of suitable frequency falls on it.
In the figure : f ≥ f₀ ⇒ electrons are emitted.
Rule 1: Experimental facts — (1) No emission below the threshold frequency f₀. (2) E_k(max) depends on f, not on intensity. (3) Emission is instantaneous (< 10⁻⁹ s). (4) Current ∝ intensity.
- Easy : f < f₀ ⇒ no emission however bright the light.
- Medium : Intensity doubled ⇒ current doubles, E_k(max) unchanged.
- Exam (CET) : E_k(max) depends on? (1) f (2) intensity (3) time (4) area → answer 1)
Rule 2: Failure of wave theory — Wave theory predicts more intensity ⇒ more E_k, no threshold and a delay in emission — all contradicting observation.
- Easy : Wave theory : energy absorbed continuously ⇒ minutes of delay.
- Medium : In reality emission is instantaneous.
- Exam (CET) : Which fact does wave theory fail to explain? (1) threshold f (2) interference (3) diffraction (4) polarisation → answer 1)
Rule 3: Work function and threshold — φ₀ = h f₀ (the minimum energy to free an electron), unit eV; λ₀ = hc ÷ φ₀.
- Easy : φ₀ = 2.3 eV ⇒ λ₀ = 1240 ÷ 2.3 = 539 nm.
- Medium : f₀ = 5 × 10¹⁴ Hz ⇒ φ₀ = 2.07 eV.
- Exam (CET) : hc = ? (1) 1240 eV nm (2) 12400 eV nm (3) 124 eV nm (4) 6.63 eV nm → answer 1)
Derivation : λ₀ = 1240 ÷ φ₀(eV) nm
- Step 1 : φ₀ = h c ÷ λ₀ (J).
- Step 2 : h c = 6.63 × 10⁻³⁴ × 3 × 10⁸ = 1.989 × 10⁻²⁵ J m.
- Step 3 : In eV : ÷ 1.6 × 10⁻¹⁹ ⇒ 1.243 × 10⁻⁶ eV m = 1243 eV nm.
- Step 4 : So λ(nm) = 1240 ÷ E(eV).
φ₀ = hf₀; λ₀(nm) = 1240/φ₀(eV).
Raising intensity does not raise E_k; raising f does.
Memory clue : "f sets the energy, intensity sets the number".
Spot the difference
| Fact | Wave theory | Photon theory |
|---|---|---|
| Threshold f | no | yes |
| E_k ∝ | intensity | f |
| Time lag | yes | instant |
Practice questions
- 1What is the threshold frequency?
- 2Unit of work function?
- 3State one experimental fact.
- 4φ₀ = 4.14 eV : λ₀?
- 5λ₀ = 620 nm : φ₀?
- 6f₀ = 8 × 10¹⁴ Hz : φ₀ (eV)?
- 72000 Å light, φ₀ = 4.2 eV : will there be emission?
- 8Intensity halved : current and E_k?
Show answers (try them yourself first)
- 1Minimum frequency for emission
- 2eV
- 3A threshold f exists
- 4λ₀ = 300 nm
- 5φ₀ = 2 eV
- 6φ₀ = 3.31 eV
- 7E = 6.2 eV ⇒ 6.2 > 4.2 ⇒ yes
- 8Current halves; E_k same
Photon energy and Einstein's photoelectric equation
A gift comes in a whole packet, not in halves — like a photon.
A photon is a packet of light energy : E = hf.
In the figure : One photon ⇒ one electron.
Photon energy and Einstein's photoelectric equation
In the app you can move this figure with your finger.
Open in the appRule 1: Photon energy — E = h f = h c ÷ λ; h = 6.63 × 10⁻³⁴ J s. The photon has zero rest mass.
- Easy : f = 1.2 × 10¹⁵ Hz ⇒ E = 4.97 eV.
- Medium : λ = 200 nm ⇒ E = 6.2 eV.
- Exam (CET) : E ∝ ? (1) f (2) λ (3) 1/f (4) f² → answer 1)
Rule 2: Einstein's equation — h f = φ₀ + E_k(max) ⇒ E_k(max) = h f − φ₀ = ½ m v²(max) = e V₀.
- Easy : E = 4.97 eV, φ₀ = 2.3 eV ⇒ E_k = 2.67 eV.
- Medium : v(max) = 9.69 × 10⁵ m/s.
- Exam (CET) : At f = f₀, E_k = ? (1) 0 (2) hf (3) φ₀ (4) ∞ → answer 1)
Rule 3: How it explains the facts — One photon gives its energy to one electron ⇒ instant; hf < φ₀ ⇒ no emission; intensity = number of photons.
- Easy : Intensity doubled ⇒ twice the photons ⇒ twice the current.
- Medium : 1 W of 500 nm light : photons/s = 1 ÷ (3.98 × 10⁻¹⁹) = 2.5 × 10¹⁸.
- Exam (CET) : Intensity ∝ ? (1) number of photons (2) f (3) λ (4) φ₀ → answer 1)
Derivation : hf = φ₀ + ½mv²
- Step 1 : Energy conservation : photon energy = work function + kinetic.
- Step 2 : Most loosely bound electron : E_k maximum.
- Step 3 : hf = φ₀ + E_k(max).
- Step 4 : E_k(max) = h(f − f₀).
E = hf = hc/λ; hf = φ₀ + E_k.
One photon gives energy to one electron, not several together.
Memory clue : "photon energy = work function + motion".
Spot the difference
| Quantity | Formula | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| E | hf = hc/λ | J, eV |
| E_k(max) | hf − φ₀ | eV |
| h | 6.63 × 10⁻³⁴ | J s; [ML²T⁻¹] |
Practice questions
- 1What is a photon?
- 2Unit of h?
- 3Einstein's equation?
- 4λ = 400 nm : E (eV)?
- 5E = 5 eV, φ₀ = 2 eV : E_k?
- 6f = 10¹⁵ Hz : E (eV)?
- 7E_k(max) = 1.5 eV, φ₀ = 2.5 eV : f?
- 8E_k(max) = 2 eV; f doubled, φ₀ = 1 eV : new E_k?
Show answers (try them yourself first)
- 1A packet of light energy
- 2J s
- 3hf = φ₀ + E_k
- 4E = 3.1 eV
- 5E_k = 3 eV
- 6E = 4.14 eV
- 7f = 9.65 × 10¹⁴ Hz
- 8E = 3 eV ⇒ E_k = 5 eV
Stopping potential, saturation current and graphs
Going up a slope, the fastest climber stops last — the stopping potential does the same for electrons.
The stopping potential V₀ stops the fastest electrons.
In the figure : Intensity ⇒ I_sat; f ⇒ V₀.
Rule 1: Stopping potential — The reverse potential V₀ that makes I = 0 : e V₀ = E_k(max) = h f − φ₀. V₀ depends on f, not intensity.
- Easy : E_k = 2.67 eV ⇒ V₀ = 2.67 V.
- Medium : E_k = 3 eV ⇒ V₀ = 3 V.
- Exam (CET) : V₀ depends on? (1) f (2) intensity (3) area (4) distance → answer 1)
Rule 2: Saturation current — When all emitted electrons reach the collector, I stops rising; I_sat ∝ intensity.
- Easy : Intensity doubled ⇒ I_sat doubles; V₀ unchanged.
- Medium : Raise f ⇒ V₀ rises; I_sat (same photon number) unchanged.
- Exam (CET) : I_sat ∝ ? (1) intensity (2) f (3) V₀ (4) φ₀ → answer 1)
Rule 3: V₀ versus f graph — A straight line : V₀ = (h/e) f − φ₀/e; slope h/e (the same for all metals); intercept on the f axis is f₀.
- Easy : Slope = 4.14 × 10⁻¹⁵ V s ⇒ h = 4.14 × 10⁻¹⁵ × 1.6 × 10⁻¹⁹ = 6.62 × 10⁻³⁴ J s.
- Medium : A different metal ⇒ a parallel line with a different f₀.
- Exam (CET) : Slope of the graph? (1) h/e (2) h (3) e/h (4) φ₀ → answer 1)
Derivation : V₀ = (h/e)(f − f₀)
- Step 1 : e V₀ = h f − φ₀.
- Step 2 : V₀ = (h/e) f − φ₀/e.
- Step 3 : y = m x + c; slope m = h/e.
- Step 4 : At V₀ = 0, f = f₀ = φ₀/h.
eV₀ = hf − φ₀; I_sat ∝ intensity; slope h/e.
V₀ does not depend on intensity; the slope does not change with the metal.
Memory clue : "intensity = number, f = speed".
Spot the difference
| Graph | What changes | What is fixed |
|---|---|---|
| I–V (intensity) | I_sat | V₀ |
| I–V (f) | V₀ | I_sat |
| V₀–f | slope h/e | same for all metals |
Practice questions
- 1Stopping potential?
- 2I_sat depends on?
- 3Slope of V₀–f?
- 4E_k = 2.5 eV : V₀?
- 5V₀ = 1.8 V, φ₀ = 2 eV : hf (eV)?
- 6Slope 4.1 × 10⁻¹⁵ : h?
- 7Does doubling f double V₀?
- 8Intensity tripled : I_sat and V₀?
Show answers (try them yourself first)
- 1Reverse potential that makes I = 0
- 2Intensity
- 3h/e
- 4V₀ = 2.5 V
- 5hf = 3.8 eV
- 6h = 6.56 × 10⁻³⁴ J s
- 7No; V₀ = (h/e)f − φ₀/e
- 8I_sat triples; V₀ same
Photon momentum, Compton scattering and the wave–particle duality of radiation
A comet's tail points away from the Sun — pushed by light pressure.
A photon's momentum is p = h/λ; light has a dual wave–particle nature.
In the figure : Photon–electron collision; p = h/λ.
Rule 1: Momentum of a photon — p = E ÷ c = h ÷ λ = h f ÷ c; zero rest mass; direction of the light.
- Easy : λ = 500 nm ⇒ p = 1.33 × 10⁻²⁷ kg m/s.
- Medium : E = 3.1 eV ⇒ p = 3.1 × 1.6 × 10⁻¹⁹ ÷ 3 × 10⁸ = 1.65 × 10⁻²⁷.
- Exam (CET) : p ∝ ? (1) 1/λ (2) λ (3) λ² (4) constant → answer 1)
Rule 2: Radiation pressure — Pressure on an absorber = I ÷ c; on a reflector = 2I ÷ c, from the photon's change of momentum.
- Easy : I = 1000 W/m² ⇒ pressure = 3.3 × 10⁻⁶ Pa (absorber).
- Medium : A reflector ⇒ double.
- Exam (CET) : Pressure on a reflector? (1) 2I/c (2) I/c (3) I c (4) I/2c → answer 1)
Rule 3: Wave–particle duality — Light behaves as a wave in interference and diffraction and as particles in photoelectric and Compton effects; no single experiment shows both together.
- Easy : Young's slits ⇒ wave.
- Medium : Photoelectric effect ⇒ particle.
- Exam (CET) : Nature of light? (1) dual (2) only wave (3) only particle (4) neither → answer 1)
Derivation : p = h ÷ λ
- Step 1 : Photon : E = pc (m₀ = 0).
- Step 2 : E = h f = h c ÷ λ.
- Step 3 : p = E ÷ c = h ÷ λ.
- Step 4 : λ = h ÷ p (the basis of de Broglie's relation).
p = h/λ = E/c; radiation pressure I/c; 2I/c.
A photon has zero rest mass but non-zero momentum.
Memory clue : "long λ — small p".
Spot the difference
| Quantity | Formula | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| p | h/λ = E/c | kg m/s |
| Pressure (absorber) | I/c | Pa |
| Pressure (reflector) | 2I/c | Pa |
Practice questions
- 1Momentum of a photon?
- 2What is duality?
- 3Pressure on a reflector?
- 4λ = 600 nm : p?
- 5I = 500 W/m² : pressure (absorber)?
- 6E = 6.2 eV : p?
- 7λ halved : p?
- 81 W fully reflected : force?
Show answers (try them yourself first)
- 1h/λ
- 2Both wave and particle properties
- 32I/c
- 4p = 1.1 × 10⁻²⁷ kg m/s
- 5Pressure = 1.67 × 10⁻⁶ Pa
- 6p = 3.31 × 10⁻²⁷ kg m/s
- 7Doubles
- 8F = 2P/c = 6.67 × 10⁻⁹ N
de Broglie wavelength of matter waves
A squirrel shows no wave nature, but an electron does.
Matter waves are waves associated with moving particles; λ = h/p.
In the figure : A particle ⇒ a wave; λ = h/mv.
Rule 1: de Broglie wavelength — λ = h ÷ p = h ÷ m v; from kinetic energy λ = h ÷ √(2 m E_k).
- Easy : Electron accelerated through 100 V : λ = 1.23 Å (= 12.27 ÷ √100).
- Medium : 0.1 kg ball at 10 m/s : λ = 6.63 × 10⁻³⁴ m (undetectable).
- Exam (CET) : λ ∝ ? (1) 1/p (2) p (3) p² (4) constant → answer 1)
Rule 2: Handy formula for electrons — An electron accelerated through V volts : λ = 12.27 ÷ √V Å; same with E in eV.
- Easy : V = 150 ⇒ λ = 1.00 Å.
- Medium : V four times ⇒ λ halves.
- Exam (CET) : V = 49 ⇒ λ? (1) 1.75 Å (2) 12.27 Å (3) 0.5 Å (4) 7 Å → answer 1) Trick : 12.27 ÷ 7.
Rule 3: Comparing particles — For the same accelerating V : λ ∝ 1/√(m q). For the same E_k : λ ∝ 1/√m.
- Easy : Proton through 100 V : λ = 2.87 × 10⁻¹² m.
- Medium : Equal E_k : λ_e ÷ λ_p = √(m_p/m_e) = 43.
- Exam (CET) : Same V : λ_p : λ_α = ? (1) 2√2 : 1 (2) 1 : 1 (3) 4 : 1 (4) 2 : 1 → answer 1)
Derivation : λ = 12.27 ÷ √V Å
- Step 1 : E_k = e V = p² ÷ 2m ⇒ p = √(2 m e V).
- Step 2 : λ = h ÷ √(2 m e V).
- Step 3 : h = 6.63 × 10⁻³⁴; m = 9.11 × 10⁻³¹; e = 1.6 × 10⁻¹⁹.
- Step 4 : λ = 12.28 ÷ √V Å ⇒ 12.27 ÷ √V Å.
λ = h/mv = h/√(2mE_k); electron : 12.27/√V Å.
λ ∝ 1/p, 1/√E_k, 1/√V; take mass in kg.
Memory clue : "12.27 ÷ √V".
Spot the difference
| Particle | Same V | Same E_k |
|---|---|---|
| λ ∝ | 1/√(mq) | 1/√m |
| e : p | 43 : 1 (e larger) | 43 : 1 |
Practice questions
- 1de Broglie's formula?
- 2The 12.27 formula for electrons?
- 3Why can't we see λ of large objects?
- 4V = 25 : λ (e)?
- 5m = 2 g, v = 5 m/s : λ?
- 6p = 3.3 × 10⁻²⁴ : λ?
- 7Electron of 100 eV : λ?
- 8Same λ : ratio of kinetic energies of e and p?
Show answers (try them yourself first)
- 1λ = h/p
- 2λ = 12.27/√V Å
- 3h is tiny ⇒ λ negligible
- 4λ = 2.45 Å
- 5λ = 6.63 × 10⁻³² m
- 6λ = 2.01 × 10⁻¹⁰ m
- 71.227 Å
- 8E_e : E_p = m_p : m_e ≈ 1833 : 1
Davisson–Germer experiment and when the wave nature shows
A CD shows rainbow colours by diffraction; electrons diffract likewise at a crystal.
The Davisson–Germer experiment experimentally confirmed the wave nature of electrons.
In the figure : 54 V electrons; maximum at φ = 50°.
Rule 1: Davisson–Germer experiment — Electrons accelerated through 54 V strike a nickel crystal; a maximum at φ = 50° confirms their wave nature.
- Easy : λ (theory) = 12.27 ÷ √54 = 1.67 Å.
- Medium : λ (experiment) = d sin φ = 2.15 × sin 50° = 1.65 Å.
- Exam (CET) : What did the experiment prove? (1) wave nature of electrons (2) photons (3) neutrons (4) α → answer 1)
Rule 2: Bragg condition — For lattice spacing d : 2 d sin θ = n λ; for the surface grating of nickel d sin φ = n λ.
- Easy : d = 2.15 Å, φ = 50°, n = 1 ⇒ λ = 1.65 Å.
- Medium : Theory and experiment nearly agree.
- Exam (CET) : Bragg's condition? (1) 2d sinθ = nλ (2) d = nλ (3) sinθ = nλ (4) d sinθ = 2nλ → answer 1)
Rule 3: When does wave nature show — Only when λ is comparable to the obstacle size. For tiny λ everyday objects behave as particles.
- Easy : An electron (λ ≈ 1 Å) diffracts at a crystal.
- Medium : A cricket ball with λ ≈ 10⁻³⁴ m shows no diffraction.
- Exam (CET) : Condition for diffraction? (1) λ ≈ size (2) λ ≫ size (3) λ ≪ size (4) any → answer 1)
Derivation : 2d sin θ = nλ
- Step 1 : Path difference of rays from adjacent planes = 2 d sin θ.
- Step 2 : Constructive interference : path difference = nλ.
- Step 3 : 2 d sin θ = n λ.
- Step 4 : Here θ is the glancing angle (from the plane).
2d sinθ = nλ; λ = 12.27/√V; diffraction needs λ ≈ size.
θ is the glancing angle, not the angle of incidence.
Memory clue : "54 V — 50° — 1.65 Å".
Spot the difference
| Experiment | Proves | Condition |
|---|---|---|
| Young/diffraction | light is a wave | — |
| Photoelectric | light is a particle | hf ≥ φ₀ |
| Davisson–Germer | electron wave | λ ≈ d |
Practice questions
- 1Who did the experiment?
- 2Which crystal was used?
- 3Significance of the experiment?
- 4V = 54 : λ?
- 5d = 2 Å, θ = 30°, n = 1 : λ?
- 6λ = 1.2 Å, d = 2.4 Å : sin θ (n = 1)?
- 7Why does a large ball not diffract?
- 8V = 150 : λ and the consequence?
Show answers (try them yourself first)
- 1Davisson and Germer
- 2Nickel
- 3Wave nature of electrons
- 4λ = 1.67 Å
- 5λ = 2.0 Å
- 6sin θ = 0.25
- 7λ is far too small
- 8λ = 1 Å ⇒ diffraction at crystals
Electron microscope and methods of electron emission
A virus can be imaged only with an electron microscope, not an optical one.
An electron microscope uses the small λ of electron waves to give high resolution.
In the figure : Gun → lenses → specimen → screen.
Rule 1: Electron microscope — Electrons with λ ≈ 0.05 Å (50 kV) give resolution about a thousand times that of a light microscope. They use magnetic or electrostatic lenses.
- Easy : 50 kV : λ = 12.27 ÷ √50000 = 0.055 Å.
- Medium : Light (500 nm) : a ≈ 300 nm; electrons : ≈ 0.03 Å.
- Exam (CET) : Better resolution when? (1) λ is small (2) λ is large (3) V is low (4) no change → answer 1)
Rule 2: Limitations — Needs a vacuum; the specimen must be thin and conducting; living specimens do not survive.
- Easy : Why a vacuum? Air molecules scatter the electrons.
- Medium : TEM shows internal structure; SEM shows surfaces.
- Exam (CET) : What does a TEM show? (1) internal structure (2) surface (3) colour (4) temperature → answer 1)
Rule 3: Ways of emitting electrons — (1) thermionic (heating), (2) field emission (strong E), (3) photoelectric, (4) secondary emission.
- Easy : A hot filament : thermionic emission.
- Medium : E ≈ 10⁸ V/m : field emission.
- Exam (CET) : A photocell uses? (1) photoelectric (2) thermionic (3) field (4) secondary → answer 1)
Derivation : Resolution depends on λ
- Step 1 : In a microscope a = 0.61 λ ÷ (n sin θ).
- Step 2 : Electrons : λ = 12.27 ÷ √V Å.
- Step 3 : Large V ⇒ small λ ⇒ small a.
- Step 4 : Hence electrons can image down to atomic scale.
e λ = 12.27/√V Å; a = 0.61λ/N.A.; methods : thermionic, field, photoelectric, secondary.
In an electron microscope a higher V means a smaller λ and better resolution.
Memory clue : "small λ = better resolution".
Spot the difference
| Method | Cause | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Thermionic | heat | filament |
| Field | strong E | FEM |
| Photoelectric | photons | photocell |
| Secondary | impact | PMT |
Practice questions
- 1Lenses used in an electron microscope?
- 2One limitation?
- 3Methods of emission?
- 4V = 10 kV : λ?
- 5λ halved : resolution?
- 6V four times : λ?
- 7a = 0.61λ/N.A., λ = 0.1 Å, N.A. = 0.01 : a?
- 8Why a vacuum for electrons?
Show answers (try them yourself first)
- 1Magnetic/electrostatic
- 2Vacuum, thin specimen
- 3Thermionic, field, photoelectric, secondary
- 4λ = 0.123 Å
- 5Resolution doubles
- 6λ halves
- 7a = 6.1 Å
- 8Air scatters electrons
Quick revision of the whole lesson
| Concept | Key formula / fact | Unit / dimensions |
|---|---|---|
| Photon | E = hf = hc/λ; λ(nm) = 1240/E(eV) | J, eV |
| Einstein | hf = φ₀ + E_k(max) | eV |
| V₀ | eV₀ = E_k(max) | V |
| Graph | V₀–f slope = h/e | V s |
| Momentum | p = h/λ = E/c | kg m/s |
| de Broglie | λ = h/mv; e : 12.27/√V Å | m |
| Davisson | 2d sinθ = nλ | Å |
| Microscope | a = 0.61λ/N.A. | m |
🎯 Most important points for the exam
- f < f₀ ⇒ no emission; E_k independent of intensity.
- hf = φ₀ + E_k; λ(nm) = 1240/E(eV).
- V₀ independent of intensity; I_sat ∝ intensity.
- Slope of the V₀–f graph is h/e.
- p = h/λ; radiation pressure I/c, 2I/c.
- λ = h/√(2mE_k); e : 12.27/√V Å.
- Diffraction needs λ ≈ size; 2d sinθ = nλ.
Start with E = hf → subtract φ₀ → E_k → V₀ = E_k/e → λ = h/p.